Tesla (TSLA) Stock Analysis
Consumer CyclicalMotor Vehicles & Passenger Car Bodies
We use a few cookies
Finrys uses only the cookies needed to sign you in and remember your preferences. No analytics or tracking.
fair value with margin of safety
This company passes only 3/8 value-investing quality checks.
“Better to buy a wonderful company at a fair price than a fair company at a wonderful price.”
Fair-value estimates are unreliable for low-quality companies. No margin of safety rescues a broken business — consider stocks with stronger fundamentals.
8-pillar fundamentals screen
Red flags — be cautiousSignals that the company may have a durable advantage
Sector: Consumer Discretionary
Automatic heuristics — always verify with the 10-K.
How the moat rating shifts the DCF — concrete parameters, not a vibe.
Without a visible moat, 10-year earnings are less defensible. We compress the terminal multiple (−3) and raise the discount rate (+1pp) to reflect real execution risk. The goal is not pessimism — it's honesty about what we can and can't forecast.
Qualitative checks a long-term investor would run
EPS volatility 420% — lower is better. Buffett prefers companies whose profits don't swing wildly year to year.
Share count changed by 263.1% over 5 years. Falling share count means each existing share owns more of the business.
Long-term debt equals 1.4 years of free cash flow. Below 4 is comfortable.
Average ROIC 13.5%. Above 15% is Buffett-grade — the company turns capital into profit efficiently.
Rule #1: 15 % over 10 years.
How consistent are revenue, EPS, equity, FCF and ROIC?
What growth is the price implying?
Market is pricing in growth above 40% annually — beyond realistic long-term bounds. Likely hyper-growth narrative priced in (AI, transformation, new category).
Market prices in growth significantly beyond historical trend. Elevated downside risk if growth disappoints.
Five independent methods triangulate a fair value band — no single number decides.
5 methods disagree widely: $5.71 – $50.39 (median $24.08). The model relies on assumptions that differ materially across methods.
Current price $396.13 sits 1545.4% above the median — above the fair-value range.
Fair value ranges from $5.71 (extra growth spend treated as a cost) to $15.96 (treated as productive investment) — a 2.8× gap. Most of the headline fair value rests on the unproven assumption that this spending pays off.
Value-investing rule: anchor on the lower figure and treat the gap as the risk you take on the reinvestment actually paying off.
Stock FAQ
Common questions about TSLA valuation, fair value, and analysis methodology.
Finrys estimates Tesla, Inc.'s (TSLA) fair value using a probability-weighted Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) model across three scenarios — bearish, base, and bullish — combined with a moat adjustment and Buffett-style quality gate. The current estimate is shown above on this page and updates automatically when new financial data is reported.
The verdict at the top of this page compares TSLA's current market price to Finrys' moat-adjusted fair value. If price exceeds fair value, the stock is flagged as potentially overvalued; if price is below fair value with a sufficient margin of safety, it is flagged as undervalued. The valuation range chart shows the spread across DCF, reverse DCF, and multiples-based estimates.
5/5 years of positive FCF. Unbroken positive FCF is one of Buffett's strongest filters.
Gross margin ~20% and stable — usually means pricing power.
Informational — great compounders often reinvest instead of paying dividends.
Tesla, Inc.'s DCF is calculated by projecting future free cash flows over 10 years and discounting them to present value at a 10% discount rate. Finrys uses three growth-rate scenarios (worst, base, best) probability-weighted into one fair value, then applies a moat-based premium or discount based on competitive advantage signals.
The valuation range chart triangulates TSLA's fair value against sector multiples (P/E, EV/EBITDA) so you can see where it sits versus comparable companies. The Buffett checklist additionally scores TSLA on 10 quality criteria — return on capital, debt levels, margin stability — that value investors use to compare durability across peers.
Compare against other S&P 500 stocks with full DCF and moat analysis.
